NARSissist Eye Shadow Palette: My Thoughts

**affiliate link**

My very first NARS eye shadow purchase of life was the NARS The NARSissist Eye Shadow Palette, $79.00 which is a limited edition release that showcases fifteen NARS signature eye shadow shades in one sleek, compact palette. One may ask why I would choose to make this my first NARS shadow purchase. Well, I had a very long wishlist of their shadows and, at the price asked, to buy even a few to try and play with I would have been up to the price of this palette. And, I had a discount. So, Beauty Blogger Math Fu kicked in and I figured that fifteen shadows that I could try, get to know then go buy my faves in full sizes in the future made sense to me. 

The packaging is classic NARS. Rectangular, rounded, solid and substantial. The palette has a weighty, luxurious feel in the hand. The surface is the typical rubbery finish with which so many NARS fans have such a passionate love/hate relationship. The finish looks fantastic when it first comes out of the box but that grabby texture gloms on to every molecule of free roaming household and makeup dust, anything on your hands, pet hair... And it is a pain in the ass to clean. Whoever thought that this packaging was a good idea clearly never owned/stored/used makeup in a real world setting. Or they just don't care. Yuk. Being the keep - my - makeup - clean - freak- that I am, this packaging drives me absolutely insane. 


The lid has an extended, rounded lip that is easy to grip with the pad of a finger to open, no frustration, no wedging small, sharp items to avoid breaking nails! The lid closes and locks down securely with a very satisfying *snap!* Inside the lid is the obligatory full sized mirror. It is large enough to see what you are doing on both eyes at the same time to enable a balanced shadow application.

In the well of the palette are fifteen small 0.003 oz eye shadows in shades ranging from palest ivory to tan, browns, lilac and purple, taupe, soft neutral peach, grey, black. Finishes range from matte to satin to shimmer and even metallic.


Here is a close up of the eye shadows in situ. The layout makes a lot of sense. The shades graduate from light to dark, soft to intense. While the pans are not large, they are sizable enough to fit an eye shadow brush, applicator or finger to pick up product without ending up falling over into the pan next door. I appreciate the thicker plastic bars between the shadows. Not only is it good looking, it is a functional feature, further aiding in keeping colour from jumping from pan to pan. There is no legend telling us the shade names on the palette or on the box.

 I want to speak about the lack of attention to detail in the assembly of the palette. NARS commands a high price for their products and yet, the pans in this palette are set in crooked. Why? For the price, the prestige of this brand, this palette should be perfect. There should be no irregularity in the set of the pans, my eye should not be disturbed by a break in crisp, straight lines. Is this nit-picking? Yes, it is. For my husband's hard earned money, I am promised high quality. I don't feel that I am out of line for asking that.


Swatches. *sigh* This is the best of a batch of challenging swatch photographs. I hate swatching on my arm, as I always blow the photos. In person, these swatches looked so much better. The first three did show up! I promise. The middle one is a near match to the skin on my arm, it doesn't lack pigmentation, it just... Blends.

The bottom shade in the first row and the bottom shade in the last row are just bad. Dry, stiff, lacking in pigmentation and patchy. The rest of the shadows are terrific. Pigmented, have very good payoff on the eye and apply and blend out beautifully. A few were a tad powdery or flaky but none were out of line. Overall, I was so impressed with the quality of the shadows. Some are becoming definite favorites. Too bad I don't know their names...

I have read a lot of complaints about the shadows in this palette. That they are not pigmented, give no payoff on the eye, blend out to nothing or are a muddy mess and just plain bad. I would like to offer photographic evidence to the contrary:



 Now, call me crazy but these shadows look pretty pigmented, to me. They applied over primer, even the deepest grey shade I used, without annoying fallout. There was plenty of pigmentation, I didn't have to pack them on or go to a lot of trouble to build them up. These shadows blended easily without flying away or becoming muddy or confused. They wore all day without creasing or fading and looked just as vibrant and beautiful when it came time to remove them as they did when I applied them.

Gentle reader, you know me. You know that if this palette were bad, I'd have no problem telling you so. I do have a couple of minor gripes about the NARSissist Eye Shadow Palette. One, is that two of the shadows are just plain awful and they are two shades that should be wonderful. Second, that grabby rubberized finish on the palette. Really, NARS? And why the hell didn't NARS stamp the shadow shade names on the palette, either on the bars that separate the pans or on the back of the palette? That was such a stupid move! There are some shades in this palette that are shaping up to be clear favorites but, because I don't know their names, I am going to have a hard time nailing them down when it comes time to go buy them in their full sizes. Badly done, NARS! You missed a great marketing opportunity.

Anyway, I like this palette. I use it more often than I thought I would and I recommend it. If you would like to try NARS shadows or expand your collection of their shadow shades but you don't want to spend a huge amount of money, maybe give this palette a go. It is available in Sephora stores and online.

Do you own this palette? What do you think of it? Please do tell... I'd love to hear your thoughts.


**affiliate links***

37 comments

  1. In spite of the small gripes, it looks like a beautiful palette, and I love the deep grey on you!

    ReplyDelete
  2. People complained about last year's palette too. I was OK with it and with this one.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I absolutely love this look on you!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Looks like a pretty awesome neutral palette to me!

    ReplyDelete
  5. The Nars packaging has always been bothersome. If you wipe it with a cotton pad saturated in alcohol, it gets rid of the gumminess and removes the rubbery texture.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I heard a lot of bad about this palette too but I love mine!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I have this and it's just...meh! I really did expect A LOT more. Man. Love your look, though!

    ReplyDelete
  8. I definitely need this palette in my life. For real.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I love the smoky look you created for this palette. Try their dual intensity e/s next time, I think you'll like the quality better.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Loved reading your honest review, and your EOTD is beautiful. It's a bummer that the shadows don't have names... I really love the look of that purplish one. Wonder why they didn't notice the pans being crooked, though - or didn't care.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I need to go back and swatch this palette again !

    ReplyDelete
  12. For that kind of money, I should hear angels singing every time I open the lid. I've thought about getting a NARS palette to try their eyeshadows... What did you think of that new, Dual-Intensity one that just came out?

    ReplyDelete
  13. Lovely shades! I think everyone could have a completely different opinion about any given palette due to a myriad of factors - so I generally pool all resources haha!

    ReplyDelete
  14. I'm glad I got to see what the inside of this really looked like. It's a nice Neutral to Smokey palette that could probably replace the Naked Palette for sure!

    ReplyDelete
  15. wow! this is nicest smokey palette I've had and still owning it. great post Erika. :)

    spafurnish.com

    ReplyDelete
  16. This is a lovely palette, but it makes my wallet weep. I probably have all these shades in various other palettes, but having them all together in this palette is nice.

    ReplyDelete
  17. If you already have them, doesn't make sense to buy this palette. LOL I just bought it as a sampler because I had such a long wishlist of shades to try. This palette actually saved me a pile of money! Hee! Hee!

    ReplyDelete
  18. It is neutral to smokey but not dull or boring. There is a nice variation of shades to play with. It's not the same thing as Naked but if you have one, you could probably live without the other. Not that I am willing to... *greedy*

    ReplyDelete
  19. I agree. Not everyone is going to love every item. The opinions on this palette run the gamut! Some love it, others hate it. And everyone seems to be pretty passionate, one way or the other! LOL It's all good, tho. There is a lot of beautiful makeup put there and plenty for everyone, for all of our tastes. :D

    ReplyDelete
  20. I haven't tried the Dual Intensity, yet. They are on my list. I have my greedy eyeballs on that new palette... I am such a palette ho. LOL


    I got this one because I had the VIB and such a long wishlist of shadows to try. In the long run, by Beauty Blogger math, it saved me money! Yep. That's my story and I'm sticking to it!

    ReplyDelete
  21. I was kind of meh on it when I swatched it. That was why I didn't buy it, when I was in Sephora, last year. I thought about it, read reviews and finally just thought... "What the hell!" and I'm happy that I did. It applies and wears better for me than it swatched. :)

    ReplyDelete
  22. Thank you. I always want to give fair, honest reviews. :D And your words are very kind. The shadows make it easy! I was surprised that they didn't give a legend of the shade names! These are signature shadows... You would think that they would want you to love them and run out and buy them in full size.


    I think that they produced a lot of palettes, fast. No excuses! For that price, I feel it should be perfect. Call me crazy or picky. :)

    ReplyDelete
  23. Thank you! I am planning the Dual Intensity to be my next NARS splurge. That and their new Audacious lipsticks. I'm DYING to try those lipsticks!

    ReplyDelete
  24. I like it muchly! Not everyone does... Opinion is polarized. But I truly do like this palette. IMO it's a good one. :D

    ReplyDelete
  25. This one is full of deeper shades so you probably wouldn't get a lot of use out of it. I have my eyes on some of the new Dual Intensity shadows, those lighter shades are just divine and calling my name!

    ReplyDelete
  26. Thank you so much. :D


    It's funny... I read pages and pages of reviews before I bought this palette and I noticed that the more positive reviews came from people with lighter and fair skin tones. The majority of the negative reviews seemed to come from people with deeper skin tones. I wonder of the shadows chosen for this palette or the formula just don't show up as well on darker skin? If that is the case, NARS needs to pay attention and fix it. That palette should have worked across the board.

    ReplyDelete
  27. I did, too. But It's working great, for me. I am really enjoying it.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Thank you. :)


    To each their own. :D

    ReplyDelete
  29. I think that any palette is going to be a hit for some, a miss for others. I have tried palettes that other people raved about and was like, "HUH???" LOL

    ReplyDelete
  30. Thank you so much. I love that shade and am going to need that one in the big size! Overall, in spite of the little gripes, I really do love this palette.

    ReplyDelete

I love to know what you're thinking. I dig honest discourse and lively discussion, even a good debate. I do not dig spam, hate speech or personal attacks either against myself or my gentle readers. Comments are moderated before they post to maintain a harmonious community.